|
I spent considerable time at the Miami Boat Show in February looking at
a new multihull offering built in South Africa--the Wildcat 350. It
certainly is an attractive looking boat with many pleasing aesthetic
features.
Personally, I could see it with a smaller cabin, stripped out interior,
and outboard power as a reasonable Class 3 racer/cruiser or sport boat.
Being offered as a solid Class 5 cruiser, I must take issue with many
features I consider unsafe, or at the least, inconvenient.
Boats, unlike automobiles or airplanes, are largely operated from
outside the vessel. Automobiles and airplanes benefit from streamlining
mostly because they move at high speeds. Sport boats and racers acquire
minimal benefits from streamlining because their design intent is to
forgo any compromise that might interfere with maximizing potential top
speed. Cruising boats are not like that. There is precious little to
gain from streamlining at cruising sailboat speeds but lots of safety
and utility to lose.
Any cruising vessel must be so configured that you can easily and
safely reach any part of the topsides or deck area of the vessel. This
is necessary for the obvious routine reasons of docking and anchoring.
This is especially poignant for cruising couples who seldom have the
advantage of the local football team to manhandle the boat around docks
or to rush forward on a slippery rounded deck with no handholds to toss
or receive a dock line.
Decks
First, the decks on the Wildcat 350 are extremely rounded, giving no
flat area anywhere upon which a person may sunbathe on a towel. Perfect
for the racer to reduce windage and cut down on weight; deadly for the
less agile trying to dock the boat.
Continuing around the deck, I noted that the stern deck quarters are so
severely sloped both downward and outward as to not only be potentially
dangerous but making it difficult to get on and off the boat safely.
Even in the benign conditions of the boat show, it was necessary to put
mats down to keep people from slipping as they clambered up from the
dock across the sloping decks and into the cockpit. That area also loses
any usefulness as deck area. I always ask potential purchasers of
cruising boats to visualize the routine of handing up groceries from the
dinghy, or even a low dock for that matter, during a rain.
There is yet another aspect to this severe slope and that is the
impossibility of putting anything on deck, even temporarily. One of my
clients, buying a Crowther-designed Offshore 44 with very much the same
characteristics, finally sold it after complaining bitterly that his
children's toys kept sliding off the boat and getting lost.
I'd suggest that anyone handing up mask and snorkel, flippers, or your
day's catch had better not lay it on that deck. Going farther around the
deck, I noted there was no toe rail. On many boats the toe rail is
molded into the deck--on some it is an extrusion, and on others it is a
decorative wooden rail, but it is there. A toe rail is an important
safety and convenience feature that should be on all cruising boats,
with rare exceptions.
|  |
Arriving at the foredeck I noted that it is so steep that you hesitate
to try and walk down, even in good weather on a new boat. What will it
be like when the weather is bad, the boat moving, and the nonskid is a
little worn? I predict that owners will install walking lines down the
center of the deck as seen in some flush deck catamarans that have
considerably less slope. This is a vital navigation area to handle
sails, anchors, docklines, etc. It's going to be tougher than it should
be for a cruising couple to launch and retrieve a spinnaker with that
deck configuration.
Cockpit
Back in the relative security of the cockpit, I found one of the
strangest anomalies yet on a cruising boat. The cockpit sole is not
level but slopes forward! This forward sloping area will undoubtedly
cause confusion and accelerated falling accidents. The anomaly continues
inside the cabin where the cabin sole slopes aft. If it is difficult to
negotiate at show dockside, how is it going to be in the open ocean?
Sloping interior decks are not good. It is especially confusing in areas
normally level, like the floor of your home. Imagine living in a house
in which the floors sloped?
Helm
The helm does have good visibility, but at what price? The helmsman's
seat is perched up on top of a pole almost out of the cockpit. The
reason it is so high is because of the oversize main bulkhead, often
called the catamaran curse. It got that name from the fact that in many
catamarans, no one but the helmsman can see forward. This massive wall
feeling is exacerbated by the forward sloping cockpit sole.
From appearances it seems that this is one of the very rare catamarans
where the helmsman could actually be hit by the boom. That also brings
up the extreme difficulty of installing a bimini, an obvious necessity
in these climes.
. . .
This may be a great boat to tear across oceans because it has all the
"speedophile" influences. However, to quote Eric Hiscock, "even the most
intrepid cruiser spends 90% of his time at anchor." Therefore, I suggest
those looking for true cruising boats weigh carefully the features
described in this article.
| Wildcat 350 |
| LOA: | 34'6" |
| BOA: | 23'0"" |
| Draft: | 3'3" |
| Sail Area: | 832 Sq. Ft. |
| Displacement: | 11,000 lbs. |
|